Has the Surge Worked?

It seems clear to Paul Greenberg that it's working. Has restored his faith, it has. Glory be!

What we seem to have actually proved is that with virtually every available American serviceman on the ground there, we can hold down the death squads. We've been able to reduce suicide bombers.

Meanwhile, with oil revenues estimated at up to $57 billion for 2008, Iraq has become one of the most corrupt countries on the planet and one of the least able to translate its wealth into meeting the needs of its citizens. Perhaps more effective than Nigeria, but definitely near the bottom. I'm a bit of a cynic. I think some of the political good will now being seen, what little there is, results from politicians recognizing that there is so much money that they can divide it up among themselves and all get rich. It will be necessary to provide some cover story for the masses, who will not do as well, but that's always possible, as George Orwell told us decades ago.

However, I'm dubious that the factions will ever trust one another enough that the U.S. can leave. The kleptocracy probably appreciates that degree of stability that having the U.S. Army constantly around the corner provides. For the U.S. taxpayer, the situation is pretty grim. It will get much worse if McCain wins in November.

Long ago, I figured the worst case for Iraq was 500 billion. How naive I was! We are now in a situation where the armed factions will agree not plunder the country rather than massacre one another if we kick in a quarter trillion a year forever. A trillion dollars is still a lot of money.